When you get cancer, how do doctors decide what treatment to give you?
At least in part, they rely on guidelines produced by the U.S. National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN). It’s a little-known group of doctors with big clout. They recommend what cancer drugs should be used in which situations.
They frequently recommend that cancer medications be used beyond the situations for which they were approved by the FDA. Big Pharma loves this. It means they sell more drugs.
And they are not cheap. Many cost more than $100,000 a year.
A new study at the Oregon Health & Science University found that there’s little or no evidence that most of the drug recommendations by the NCCN are effective.1
Dr. Vinjay Prasad led the study. He says the new findings “raise concern that the NCCN justifies the coverage of costly, toxic cancer drugs based on weak evidence.”
Pushing Unproven Cancer Drugs
Dr. Prasad and his team compared FDA approvals of cancer drugs with NCCN recommendations. When the NCCN made recommendations beyond the FDA’s approvals, they evaluated the evidence behind them.
The FDA approved 47 new cancer drugs for 69 indications over the study period. But the NCCN recommended these drugs for 113 uses. That’s 39% more recommendations than what the FDA approved the drugs for. And out of their 44 additional recommendations, only six would eventually get FDA approval.
Even more concerning?
Only 10 of these additional recommendations were based on evidence from randomized controlled trials. Just seven were based on evidence from phase III studies that tested the safety of these drugs. Most relied on small, uncontrolled studies or case reports…or didn’t offer any evidence.
So why does the NCCN push unproven cancer drugs?
The Big Pharma Connection
The study points out that 86% of NCCN members have financial ties to the pharmaceutical industry, with 84% of them receiving personal payments. And 47% get research payments.
The NCCN endorsement is linked to reimbursement by commercial insurers and social insurance schemes.
It’s something Dr. Prasad has studied before. And he found that it isn’t just the NCCN. The FDA also has a tendency to over-approve these drugs.
The agency argues that trials proving effectiveness often take many years. Cancer patients need help now. They say it’s better to roll out a medication quickly and then monitor its effectiveness. If it doesn’t work, the drug can always be pulled from the market. If it does work, lives will be saved.
This may sound sensible. But in practice, it’s not working. Only a small percentage of the new FDA-approved cancer drugs end up helping patients live longer.
Dr. Prasad looked at 36 cancer drugs that the FDA approved without proof they helped patients live longer. More than four years later, only five had shown evidence of improved survival. That’s a failure rate of 86%.2
And even after a medication shows it is useless, the FDA is often slow to pull it from the market. So patients keep on taking it, not realizing their drug is a proven failure. This means years of “bonus” profit for Big Pharma.
Don’t Be a Cancer Drug Guinea Pig
Since you can’t rely on the FDA or the NCCN to tell you which drugs work and which ones don’t, you have to do your own research. Before you try a new drug, ask your oncologist these eight questions:4
- Has the drug shown survival benefits in clinical trials? If your doctor prescribes a drug treatment for cancer, ask for the evidence that it works. How long did patients live versus those taking a placebo or other drugs?
- Has the drug been tested in patients like me? Look for human studies that show the medication has been effective in patients with the same type of cancer and similar age, treatment histories, etc.
- Are the survival benefits greater than older, less risky drugs?
- If the drug is in ongoing trials, can I get preliminary results? Also ask about the results in animal trials.
- Is the medication approved in other countries? If so, what is its track record there?
- What side effects am I likely to have? Will any of them be permanent?
- Are there related drugs in the same class that are effective?
- Will the drug be covered by insurance?
Editor’s Note: We’ve uncovered one of the most shocking conspiracies of all time… A scheme to suppress a stunningly effective treatment for cancer…and keep it hidden from the patients who desperately need it. Get all the details HERE.
Like this Article? Forward this article here or Share on Facebook.
References:
1 https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2018-03/b-uct030618.php
2 http://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/2463590
3 http://www.breastcancer.org/treatment/targeted_therapies/herceptin/how_works
4 http://www.nextavenue.org/7-questions-ask-about-every-new-prescription/